and craig you guys decided to take on the israeli government two thousand and five why did this take so long i mean you guys just got a verdict last year well of course it started. right at the rate was killed when we through diplomatic channels to find some sort of answer and actually president bush was promised a thorough credible and transparent investigation by the israelis the prime minister sharon promising that the day after it was killed but in two thousand and four we heard in writing that. of course they had done some sort of investigation but they came back exonerating the soldiers and everything but even our own state department then said that did not meet the standard being credible and transparent so with that promise made by the president but we kept pushing through diplomatic channels but with two years running we had to file something because that's the only way we could push it forward then i think there was a law passed in the knesset saying that nobody in the. palestinian territories could bring a lawsuit that was made retroactive that had to be challenge should g